Is Yoga Research Tantamount to Discredited Prayer Research?

Published on
April 2, 2014

Slate contributor Brian Palmer recently dubbed yoga “the new prayer: the risk-free, cost-free solution to all of your medical problems.” Scientific evidence to date, contends Palmer, is vastly outpaced by the cultural myth of yoga’s effectiveness, and yoga’s benefits are unlikely to outperform those of exercise. Yet while yoga and prayer have shared origins in spiritual or religious traditions, there are wide-ranging implications should such origins preclude empirical investigation.

For one, the impact of spirituality, religion, and mindfulness on health and wellbeing would remain unstudied; a great loss, as such research frequently indicates beneficial effects. In addition, while many yoga practitioners conceptualize yoga as a spiritual practice, many also perceive it as primarily secular and fitness-based. Such differences in belief may circumscribe or moderate research outcomes. It is unlikely that those who pray share a similar dichotomization.

Palmer raises a number of valid concerns, although none warrant his conclusion that “yoga doesn’t … fit into a clinical trial.” Among them: The heterogeneity of yoga practices are difficult to operationalize and assess. Which components are most effective, and for which medical concerns? In yoga’s defense, this issue applies to most modalities of Complementary and Alternative Medicine (CAM).

Dr. Crystal Park (full disclosure: my mentor) and colleagues are taking the first step towards tackling this concern. Their NCCAM-funded project is developing an instrument that assesses the extent to which various yoga practices, philosophical elements, and other components are featured in yoga interventions. Researchers will then be able to assess whether certain aspects of yoga interventions are more predictive of successful outcomes than other aspects.

Palmer also expresses qualms regarding individual differences in yoga practice. What about those who breathe deeper, hold poses longer, or meditate “better”? Yet similar issues confound exercise intervention research lacking objective measurements, which may assign exercise homework at a particular intensity, only to be confounded by individual differences in metabolism, exertion, errors in self-reporting, or so on.

Likewise, those prescribed homework in a psychotherapy intervention may differ on the extent to which they privately and successfully implement the strategies or techniques. Such issues arise across many forms of intervention research and can be rectified with the use of objective instrumentation, such as ecological momentary assessment and accelerometers.

Most problematic, for Palmer, are the methodological weaknesses characterizing yoga research to date. Most published reviews of yoga’s benefits conclude that the poor quality of trials precludes definitive conclusions regarding yoga’s efficacy, and a surprisingly large number of trials demonstrate null findings (i.e., no effect). When studies do not fit with yoga’s image as cure-all, the mainstream media fails to report them, engendering a highly skewed popular perception of yoga’s benefits. Yet the media has long cherry-picked sexier research findings while ignoring their homelier, non-significant counterparts. Take, for instance, the notoriously changeable media reputation of nutrition, weight loss, and dietary supplement research, due to selective reporting.

While yoga may be no more effective than exercise, as Palmer argues, yoga curricula have been linked to improvements in characteristics related to health and well-being in other studies, including mindfulness, self-compassion, spirituality, and the relaxation response. Such gains are unlikely to result from participation in exercise alone. When these components are combined with (and/or result from) yogic practices, a “whole system” emerges that may synergistically outperform the sum of its parts. Neglecting to assess these components and their additive effects because of yoga’s origins in spirituality would represent a great oversight (and disservice) to science and public health, both of which stand to gain from a better understanding of behaviors that may interweave multiple health benefits in one package.

Nevertheless, Palmer is absolutely correct that yoga’s PR image has vastly outgrown the emerging scientific evidence base. I can understand why, to the staunch empiricist or those wary of CAM, yoga research may at best be viewed as squandering time and resources, at worst threatening the foundations of empiricism itself. After all, yoga’s pop culture friendliness with astrology, new ageism, and magical thinking do little to assist perceptions of its worthiness for scientific study. Yet Palmer’s critiques of yoga research apply equally to CAM and other forms of intervention research, and are addressable with time, funding, and increased methodological rigor.

Perhaps the best inadvertent rebuttal to Palmer’s piece is a recent article published in prestigious medical journal The Lancet, Should Your Patient Be Doing Yoga? Says Shri Mishra of the University of Southern California, “We have not reached a point where we can say there is good scientific evidence that yoga is beneficial. Despite [this], many patients do seem to benefit. There is therefore every reason to continue researching into this area to determine which patients, with which medical conditions, attending which type of yoga class, might profit from its practice.”

Share with

Friends

Our Latest

Yoga Articles
  • Demonstrating What Is Pranayama

    What Is Pranayama? (Definition, Purpose, History, Stages and Types)

  • Self Realization

    Self Realization: Definition, Qualities and Benefits

  • Yoga With Meditation

    Combining Yoga With Meditation: Tips, Benefits, and Expert Advice

  • What Is Meditation

    What Is Meditation? (Definition, History, Types, and Styles)

  • Chakra Stones

    Chakra Stones & Crystals: Types, Meaning and Use

  • Mental Health Benefits of Yoga

    10 Tips for Harnessing the Mental Health Benefits of Yoga

  • Best Time to Meditate

    Finding the Best Time to Meditate: Tips and Advice on When to Sit

  • Purusharthas

    Purusharthas: The Four Goals of Life

Remove Ads with a

Premium Membership

Viewing ads supports YogaBasics, which allows us to continue bringing you quality yoga content. Sign up for a premium membership to remove all ads and enjoy uninterrupted access to the best yoga resources on the web.

Explore More

Yoga TipsAdviceArticlesPracticesBasicsTechniques

  • Yoga practice community

    How to Find Your Practice Community

  • Yoga Intentions, Goals, Resolutions & Affirmations

    Choosing Intentions, Resolutions & Affirmations for Positive Change

  • Yoga astrology element

    Yoga and Astrology: Find the Best Practices for Your Sign

  • yoga pose symbol

    5 Popular Yoga Poses And What They Symbolize

  • Restarting a yoga practice

    11 Ways to Reboot Your Yoga Practice

  • benefits of using props

    5 Ways Using Props Will Deepen Your Yoga Practice

  • Back-bending Yoga Pose for Envy

    Stop, Breathe and Shift: How to Conquer Yoga Envy

  • Yoga Affects Body Image

    The Powerful Link Between Yoga and Body Satisfaction

  • Skillful Yoga Student handstand pose

    8 Qualities of a Skillful Yoga Student

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Tosca Park Avatar
About the author
Tosca Park, a 200-hour Kripalu Yoga instructor and 500-hour Integrative Yoga Therapist, is a doctoral student in Clinical Health Psychology at the University of Connecticut, where she conducts research on yoga, mindfulness, and health with her mentor, Dr. Crystal Park, and collaborators. Prior to UConn Tosca spent five years as a research intern and project manager with Kripalu’s Institute for Extraordinary Living, an organization devoted to the scientific study of yoga-based curricula. She holds bachelor’s degrees from Reed College and SUNY Empire State College in history and health psychology, respectively, and has more than 2,000 hours of training in yoga, Ayurveda, and the mind-body connection.
Yoga Basics